Updated for FY 2026-27

Which Job Offer Should You Take? (India Calculator)

Compare two offers on what actually matters — the money left in your pocket after tax, PF and the cost of living in each city. Not CTC. Not a guessed score.

🏆 Offer B wins

₹17,753 more in your pocket every month

after income tax, PF and the cost of living in Pune — even though Offer A has the higher CTC.

85% · ₹11.9L

15% (₹2.1L) is variable / bonus — not guaranteed

min
100% · ₹12L

Entire CTC is fixed

min
Tax regime
Offer AOffer B
Annual CTC₹14L₹12L
Fixed (guaranteed) CTC₹11.9L₹12L
Monthly in-hand (fixed pay)₹89,447₹90,200
Living cost / month₹85,000₹68,000
Money left over / month₹4,447₹22,200
Total in-hand over 3 years₹34.8L₹35L
Variable / bonus (not guaranteed)₹2.1L₹0

Why Offer B wins for you

  • ₹753 more in-hand every month
  • ₹17,000 lower living cost in Pune
  • 30 min shorter commute each way

⏱️ Commute over a year: Offer A20 days vs Offer B10 days spent travelling (round trip, ~22 working days/month). Time you never get back.

Estimates only. In-hand is computed on fixed pay after income tax (FY 2026-27), 12% employee PF and professional tax, assuming basic = 40% of CTC. Variable pay, joining bonuses and ESOPs are shown separately because they are not guaranteed monthly income. Living costs are editable estimates for a comfortable single person (rent + essentials). Old-regime figures here assume PF as the only 80C deduction — use the CTC calculator for HRA and full deductions.

Stop comparing job offers by CTC

You have two offer letters open. One shows a bigger CTC, and your gut says take it. But CTC — Cost to Company — is what your employer budgets to keep you, not what reaches your bank account. It bundles the employer's PF contribution, gratuity, insurance, and a variable bonus you might never see in full. The number that actually decides your life is your monthly in-hand from guaranteed (fixed) pay, and then what is left of it after you pay rent and live in that city. This calculator compares offers on exactly that — and gives you a clear winner in rupees.

The three things that actually separate two offers

1. Fixed vs variable pay. A ₹14 lakh CTC with 85% fixed pay (₹11.9 lakh guaranteed) is a genuinely different offer from a ₹14 lakh CTC that is 100% fixed. Variable pay depends on company performance, your rating, and whether the bonus pool survives a bad quarter. This tool calculates your in-hand on the fixed portion only and shows the variable as a separate, clearly-labelled upside — so you are never fooled by a fat headline number that is half conditional.

2. Cost of living.₹90,000 in-hand in Bengaluru and ₹76,000 in Pune are closer than they look once rent is paid. Bengaluru and Mumbai routinely cost ₹15,000–25,000 more per month than a Tier-2 city for the same lifestyle. The "money left over" row subtracts a realistic monthly living cost from each offer's in-hand, so you compare disposable income — the rupees you can actually save or spend — not gross salary.

3. The long game. A higher starting salary compounds through every future hike. The 3-year projection grows both offers at the same hike rate and re-applies tax each year, so you can see whether a small gap today becomes a large one by year three — or whether it barely matters.

How the winner is decided

Unlike score-based tools that invent a number out of weighted opinions, this calculator picks a winner on one objective measure: money left in your pocket each month after living costs. That is a real rupee figure you can verify, not a 0–100 score someone made up. Commute time, variable-pay upside and ESOPs are shown as context so you can override the money verdict with your own priorities — but the headline answer stays honest and defensible.

Worked example: ₹14L Bangalore (MNC) vs ₹12L Pune (smaller firm)

Offer A — ₹14 LPA, Bengaluru, 85% fixed. Fixed CTC = ₹11.9 lakh. Monthly in-hand on the fixed pay works out to roughly ₹89,000 (new regime, after tax, PF and professional tax). Bengaluru living costs about ₹85,000/month for a comfortable single person, so money left over ≈ ₹4,000. The remaining ₹2.1 lakh of CTC is variable — paid only if targets are met.

Offer B — ₹12 LPA, Pune, 100% fixed. Fixed CTC = ₹12 lakh. Monthly in-hand ≈ ₹90,000. Pune living costs about ₹68,000/month, so money left over ≈ ₹22,000.

Verdict: Offer B — the lower-CTC offer — leaves you roughly ₹18,000 more every month to save, despite a ₹2 lakh smaller CTC. It is also 100% guaranteed, with no variable-pay risk and a shorter commute. Offer A only pulls ahead if its full variable bonus pays out every year and you specifically want the larger company on your résumé. This is the kind of result that looks backwards on the offer letter and obvious once you do the real math.

Frequently asked questions

12 LPA in Bangalore vs 10 LPA in Pune — which is actually better?

Run both above and look at the 'money left over per month' row, not the CTC. A ₹12 LPA Bangalore offer gives roughly ₹90,000 in-hand, but Bangalore living costs ~₹85,000/month leaves about ₹5,000. A ₹10 LPA Pune offer gives ~₹75,000 in-hand against ~₹68,000 living costs, leaving ~₹7,000. So the lower-CTC Pune offer can leave you with more savings every month. That is the whole point of this tool — the higher number on the offer letter is often not the better deal once rent and cost of living are factored in.

Should I take a startup offer or an MNC offer?

Compare them on guaranteed (fixed) in-hand first, which this calculator does by default. Startups often pack a big chunk of CTC into variable pay and ESOPs — money that may never fully arrive. Set the startup's fixed-pay slider to its real guaranteed portion and you will usually see the gap shrink or reverse. Treat ESOPs as a lottery ticket, not salary: count them at zero, and if they pay out, it is a bonus. An MNC's lower headline number is often more cash in your bank, more reliably.

Why compare in-hand instead of CTC?

CTC (Cost to Company) is what your employer budgets for you — it includes the employer's PF contribution, gratuity provision, insurance and a variable bonus you might not get. None of that is money in your bank account. In-hand is what actually reaches you each month after tax, PF and professional tax. Two offers with the same CTC can have very different in-hand depending on the fixed-vs-variable split and salary structure. Always compare jobs on real take-home, never on CTC.

How should I value the ESOPs in a job offer?

Honestly? Assume zero until they vest and you can actually sell them. Most startup ESOPs expire worthless because the company never has a liquidity event at a higher valuation. If you want to factor them in, treat them as a separate upside scenario — not as part of your monthly salary. This calculator deliberately keeps variable pay and ESOPs out of the monthly winner so you compare on guaranteed cash, then decide for yourself how much weight the upside deserves.

Is a higher salary worth a longer commute?

Look at the commute reality-check line above. A 60-minute one-way commute is about 44 full days a year spent travelling versus a 20-minute commute. If the higher-paying offer only leaves you a few thousand rupees more per month but costs you 30+ extra days a year and daily stress, many people are better off with the closer, slightly lower-paying job. There is no universal answer — but seeing the time cost in days rather than minutes usually changes how people decide.

Does this calculator work for the old tax regime?

Yes — switch the tax regime toggle to 'old'. Note that in old-regime mode this tool assumes your PF is your only 80C deduction and does not apply HRA exemption, so it is a conservative estimate. For a precise old-regime figure including HRA, rent, 80C and 80D, use the CTC to In-Hand Salary Calculator, then bring those numbers back here to compare. For most salaried people in FY 2026-27, the new regime gives higher in-hand anyway.

Related tools